plant lover, cookie monster, shoe fiend
20187 stories
·
20 followers

Looking in the Wrong Places: Rethinking Female Literacy in Ancient Egypt  - ARCE

1 Share

Fig 1. Seshat, goddess of writing

In 1971, art historian Linda Nochlin famously asked, “Why Have There Been No Great Women Artists?”. Examining the Western artistic canon, Nochlin argued that instead of asking where female artists are, we should instead ask why they are absent from the modern historical record. Talented female artists existed but societal structures and institutional obstacles often prevented them from gaining recognition in artistic circles. Though Nochlin spoke of modern art in the Western world, this shift in perspective is relevant to the search for female literacy in ancient Egypt (defined here as any ability to read or write). While male literacy is well-documented through titles and monuments, the lack of evidence for women may reflect where we are looking, not whether female literacy existed. 

The Traditional Model of Literacy 

In ancient Egypt, male scribes held positions of high status in the royal administration. Their literacy was formal, taught in elite schools, publicly commemorated in tombs and monuments, and an important tool in curating social status.  Women, by contrast, were largely excluded from scribal training, as their expected roles mainly centred around the household and child-rearing. Other roles included temple priestesses, musicians, dancers, seamstresses, midwives, wet nurses, or very rarely, physicians. 

Because the traditional model of literacy is tied to the administration of Egypt, it is unsurprising that early scholarship found little evidence of a female equivalent. The feminine form of the scribal title, ‘sšt’, though rare, is attested. Yet, as Mariam Ayad has recently demonstrated, it has consistently been dismissed within Egyptological scholarship as evidence for female literacy. In 1969, Posener translated sšt as “scribe of her mouth,” interpreting it to mean “cosmetician”—someone responsible for applying makeup to a woman’s lips—despite the lack of evidence for lip cosmetics in ancient Egypt, an interpretation which proved popular. Ayad, however, convincingly argues that sšt is better understood as “(female) scribe of her utterance,” possibly referring either to a woman serving another in a secretarial capacity or to a scribe recording her own creative expression. Regardless of its exact meaning, by focusing only on elite titles, we overlook alternative contexts where women may have read and written, namely in the domestic and private spheres.  

Gay Robins, in her work on gender and sexuality, importantly stresses that most surviving texts and monuments from ancient Egypt were produced by and for (elite) men, which limits our understanding of women’s lives. Women may have gained literacy within royal or private households, especially among temple communities or elite families, and used it in informal ways not captured by official titles or records. Robins also emphasises that literacy was not a social marker for women as it was for men. A woman’s value was not tied to her literacy, which may explain why her skills were not commemorated in tombs or titles. 

Collating the Evidence 

Baines and Eyre’s 1983 article, “Four Notes on Literacy,” was the first to collect evidence of female literacy from across ancient Egyptian history. Alongside scribal titles and attributes, more ‘indirect’ evidence was presented, such as a writing palette of the Amarna princess Meketaten, a Late Ramesside letter referencing a potentially literate woman, correspondence addressed to and sent by women, letters to the dead from women, love poems written from a woman’s perspective, and references to female writing in mythology and stories (e.g., Seshat as the goddess of writing and, the Demotic story of Setne Khamwas and Naneferkaptah which speaks of the wife of a prince who can read and write). These examples were tentatively presented but emphasised the need to search outside the scribal elite for signs of female literacy. 

Fig 2. Princess Meketaten’s palette (18th Dynasty), Metropolitan Museum of Art

Visual Evidence: Theban Tomb Scenes 

By 1984, art historian Betsy Bryan took a closer look at New Kingdom tombs, particularly in Thebes, identifying depictions of women with scribal palettes beneath their chairs. Previously dismissed as decorative or associated with nearby men, Bryan argued these attributes were intentional. In some scenes, women appear alone with palettes under their own seats. Most, such as the Dynasty 19 figure Henuttawy in TT69, held temple titles like “Songstress of Amun,” suggesting how their literacy may have been used. They were likely not professional scribes but part of a class where administrative roles, and the associated literacy, held social value. 

Fig 3. Scribal palette beneath Henuttawy’s chair, Tomb of Menna (TT69)

Case Study: Henuttawy’s Letter 

In a Late Ramesside letter (LRL 58), Henuttawy, the wife of the necropolis scribe Menna, references an earlier message from her husband and appears to act on his behalf in official matters. Scholars have debated whether she physically wrote the letter herself, but her administrative role, documented in both the letter and taxation records, suggests some degree of literacy. Deborah Sweeney also noted that Henuttawy quotes directly from a prior letter, an act that likely required reading ability. Whilst Henuttawy held no official title, she demonstrates that female literacy could exist in informal, household-based, or auxiliary administrative contexts that rarely made it into the formal record. 

Non-Elite Evidence: Deir el-Medina 

Perhaps the strongest case for female literacy comes from Deir el-Medina, a workmen’s village near Thebes. This unique archaeological site preserves an abundance of textual ostraka, small sherds of pottery used for legal, administrative, and more informal writing such as letters, shopping lists, and personal notes among others. One ostrakon (O. DeM 132) records a woman named Ese asking another, Nubemnu, to make a shawl and sanitary towel. Sweeney argues that these letters could have been written and read aloud by scribes, but this seems an unnecessary inconvenience given the relatively small size of the community where messages could be passed along verbally. The sheer volume of texts also suggests a broader literacy base. Additionally, Toivari-Viitala shows that some girls in Deir el-Medina may have received informal education, providing a possible avenue to literacy. 

A Needed Shift in Focus 

The search for female literacy in ancient Egypt highlights broader issues in how we study the past: whose stories get preserved and what types of evidence we consider valid. As interest continues to grow in gender studies, domestic life, and household archaeology, we may uncover more traces of literate women, not in formulaic, elite inscriptions, but in humble scraps of pottery, marginal tomb scenes, and overlooked letters. Until then, the absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. Literate women existed. We just need to look in the right places. 

Selected Bibliography 

Ayad, M. F., ‘Moving Beyond Gender Bias’, in M. F. Ayad (ed.), Women in Ancient Egypt (Cairo: The American University in Cairo Press, 2022), 29–59. 

Baines, J. and Eyre, C., ‘Four Notes on Literacy’, Göttinger Miszellen 61 (1983), 65-96. 

Bryan, B. M., ‘Evidence for Female Literacy from Theban Tombs of the New Kingdom’, Bulletin of the Egyptological Seminar 6 (1984), 17-32.  

Janssen, J. J., ‘A Notable Lady’, Wepwawet: Research Papers in Egyptology 2 (1986), 30-31.  

Nochlin, L., ‘Why Have There Been No Great Women Artists?’, in V. Gornick and B. K. Moran (eds), Woman in Sexist Society: Studies in Power and Powerlessness (New York, 1971), 480 -511.  

Robins, G., Women in Ancient Egypt (London, 1993). 

Sweeney, D., ‘Henuttawy’s Guilty Conscience’, JEA 80 (1994), 208-212. 

Sweeney, D., ‘Women’s Correspondence from Deir el-Medina’, in G. M. Zaccone (ed.) Congresso Internazionale di Egittologia: Atti, Proceedings of the International Congress of Egyptology, Turin, Italy, 1-8 September 1992 II (Turin, 1993), 523-539.  

Toivari-Viitala, J., Women at Deir el-Medina: A Study of the Status and Roles of the Female Inhabitants in the Workmen’s Community during the Ramesside Period (EU 15; Leiden, 2001).  

 

Read the whole story
sarcozona
1 hour ago
reply
Epiphyte City
Share this story
Delete

Autophagy in Stress-Induced Neuropsychiatric Disorders and Depression | Dementia and Cognitive Impairment | JAMA Psychiatry | JAMA Network

1 Share

A central question in neuroscience and psychiatry is the mechanism(s) through which acute and chronic stress impact and reshape brain homeostasis. These mechanisms, including redox signaling, inflammatory response, and metabolic cascade, physiologically contribute to homeostatic maintenance of cells and the body and underlie the pathophysiology of mental disorders.1 Autophagy is an evolutionarily conserved mechanism, involving the sequestration of cytoplasmic organelles, lipid vesicles, and misfolded proteins, and is regarded as a central cellular process of homeostatic maintenance.1,2 This process is mechanistically connected with the metabolic cascade and other stress-mediated cascades, initiated by specific sensor proteins such as 5′ adenosine monophosphate–activated protein kinase (AMPK) and mammalian target of rapamycin (mTOR).1,2 Autophagy-related 7 (ATG7), ATG12, Beclin-1, and Sequestosome-1/p62 are representative executors and mediators of the autophagic process.1,2

Read the whole story
sarcozona
14 hours ago
reply
Epiphyte City
Share this story
Delete

compostablespork (@compostablespork@weirder.earth)

1 Share
Read the whole story
sarcozona
21 hours ago
reply
Epiphyte City
Share this story
Delete

Declassified files expose British role in NATO’s Gladio terror armies - The Grayzone

1 Comment

Newly declassified British Foreign Office files have added disturbing details to the history of Operation Gladio. The covert operation was uncovered in 1990, when the public learned that the CIA, MI6 and NATO trained and directed an underground army of fascist paramilitary units across Europe, deploying its assets to undermine political opponents, including through false flag terror attacks.

Among them was a young Silvio Berlusconi, the media oligarch who served as Italian Prime Minister in four separate governments between 1994 and 2011. Listed as a member of the P2, the secret Cold War-era cabal of political elites devoted to Gladio’s aims, Berlusconi undoubtedly took some weighty secrets to the grave when he died this June 12th.

It is almost impossible to believe that inconvenient truths were not weeded from Britain’s documentary record on Operation Gladio prior to declassification. Nonetheless, the recently released material is highly illuminating. Covering a fraught twelve month period after the first public disclosure of Gladio’s existence, the papers illustrate how London’s foreign intelligence apparatus kept a keen eye on the continent as events unfolded.

The papers not only shed fresh light on the conspiracy, they underline Gladio’s relevance as British intelligence joins its America counterparts in contemporary plots involving secret partisan forces from Syria to Ukraine. 

Various passages dotted across the tranche strongly suggest the British knew much more than they publicly admitted about egregious criminal deeds, including the attempted overthrow of an allied Italian government and the kidnap and murder of its leader.

A ‘clandestine resistance network’ goes to work

Gladio consisted of a constellation of “stay behind” anti-communist partisan armies whose ostensible mission was to fend off the Red Army in the event of Soviet invasion. In reality, these forces committed countless violent and criminal acts as part of a “strategy of tension” designed to discredit the left and justify a security state clampdown.

As Vincenzo Vinciguerra, a Gladio operative jailed for life in 1984 for a car bombing in Italy that killed three police officers and injured two, explained:

“You were supposed to attack civilians, women, children, innocent people from outside the political arena. The reason was simple, force the public to turn to the state and ask for greater security…People would willingly trade their freedom for the security of being able to walk the streets, go on trains or enter a bank. This was the political logic behind the bombings. They remain unpunished because the state cannot condemn itself.”

The scandal triggered in Western capitals by the exposure of Gladio dominated mainstream headlines for months. The European parliament responded by passing a resolution condemning the existence of a “clandestine parallel intelligence and armed operations organization [which] escaped all democratic controls, may have interfered illegally in the internal political affairs of member states [and] have at their disposal independent arsenals and military resources…thereby jeopardizing the democratic structures of the countries in which they are operating.”

The resolution called for independent judicial and parliamentary investigations into Gladio in every European state. But aside from inquiries in Belgium, Italy, and Switzerland, nothing of substance materialized. What’s more, investigators heavily redacted their findings while avoiding having them translated them into English. This may help explain why the historic scandal has been largely forgotten.

In this context, the newly declassified documents may be one of the most valuable primary sources to date offering new insights into the origins and internal workings of NATO’s secret terror militias in Italy. 

Take for example an aide-mémoire (see it here) prepared by Francesco Fulci, Italy’s permanent representative to the UN, which was shared at a “super-restricted” November 6th 1990 meeting of the North Atlantic Council, NATO’s principal political decision-making body, then forwarded to senior British officials at home and abroad.

Based on a note provided by Rome’s then-premier Giulio Andreotti to “the Head of the Italian Parliamentary Commission investigating terrorist incidents,” the aide-mémoire begins by noting that following World War II, Western intelligence agencies devised “unconventional means of defence, by creating in their territories a hidden network of resistance aimed at operating, in case of enemy occupation, through information gathering, sabotage, propaganda and guerrilla warfare.”

According to the aide-mémoire, authorities in Rome began laying the foundations of such an organization in 1951. Four years later, Italian Military Intelligence (SIFAR) and “a corresponding allied service” – a reference to the CIA – then formally agreed on the organization and the activities of a “post-occupation clandestine network”:

“[Gladio] was; formed by agents active in the territory who, by virtue of their age, sex and activities, could reasonably avoid eventual deportation and-imprisonment by the foreign occupiers; easy to manage even from a command structure outside the occupied territory; at a top secret level and hence subdivided into ‘cells’ so as to minimize any possible damage caused by defections, accidents or network penetration.”

The “clandestine resistance network” was subdivided into separate branches, covering information operations, sabotage, propaganda, radio communications, cypher, reception and evacuation of people and equipment. Each of these structures was to operate autonomously, “with liaison and coordination ensured by an external base.” 

SIFAR established a dedicated, secret section to recruit and train Gladio operatives. Meanwhile, it maintained five “ready deployment guerrilla units in areas of special interest” across Italy which awaited activation on a continuous basis.

“Operational materials”, including a wide variety of explosives, weapons – such as mortars, hand grenades, guns and knives – and ammunition were stashed in 139 secret underground caches across the country. In April 1972, “to improve security,” these arsenals were exhumed, and moved to offices of the Carabinieri, Rome’s military police, near the original sites. 

Only 127 of the weapons storehouses were officially recovered. The aide-mémoir states that at least two “were very likely taken away by unknown persons” at the time they were buried, in October 1964. Who these operatives were and what they did with their stolen arms is left to the imagination.

British involvement in the coup effort

Fulci was eventually quizzed by attendees of the North Atlantic Council summit “as to whether Gladio had deviated from its proper objectives.” In other words, beyond operating strictly as a “stay behind” force, to be activated in the event of Soviet invasion. While “he could not add to what was in the aide-mémoire,” Fulci confirmed “weapons used in some terrorist incidents had come from stores established by Gladio.”

This may reflect the fact that political violence was one of Gladio’s “proper objectives.” A June 1959 SIFAR report unearthed by historian Daniele Ganser confirms guerrilla action against “domestic threats” was hardwired into the operation from its inception. In the Italian context, this entailed systematically terrorizing the left.

As the Italian Communist party surged in polls ahead of the country’s 1948 election, the CIA pumped money into the coffers of the Christian Democrats and an attendant anti-communist propaganda campaign. The cloak-and-dagger effort was so successful in preventing the outbreak of a left-wing government in Rome that Langley secretly intervened in every one of Rome’s elections for at least the next 24 years.

Yet the covert CIA operations were insufficient to prevent Italians from occasionally electing the wrong governments. The 1963 general election saw the Christian Democrats prevail again, this time under the leadership of left-leaning politician Aldo Moro, who sought to construct a coalition with the Socialists and Democratic Socialists. Over the next year, protracted disputes erupted between these parties over what form their administration would take.

In the meantime, SIFAR and CIA black ops specialists such as William Harvey, known as “America’s James Bond,” cooked up a plot to prevent that government from taking office. Known as “Piano Solo,” it dispatched Gladio operatives for a false flag assassination attempt on Moro that would deliberately fail. 

According to the plan, the kidnapper was expected to claim they were ordered to kill Moro by communists, thereby justifying the violent seizure of multiple political party and newspaper headquarters, along with the imprisonment of troublesome leftists at the Gladio chapter’s secret headquarters in Sardinia. The plan was ultimately aborted, though it remained on the table throughout 1964.

Moro became Prime Minister without incident and governed until June 1968. Piano Solo fell under official investigation four years later, yet the results were not published until the public first learned of Gladio’s existence. Though the findings omitted any reference to Britain’s role in the planned coup, the newly released documents strongly suggest London’s involvement. (Read them here).

Italy’s then-President Francesco Cossiga requested the ministry hand over “details of UK stay behind measures in 1964,” according to a detailed February 1991 Foreign Office memo on recent developments in the scandal.

Cossiga apparently made this enquiry as a result of a judge “whose investigations into unsolved terrorist attacks first brought Operation Gladio to light,” and who took the “unprecedented step” of demanding the president testify about the conspiracy under oath. By this point, Cossiga had admitted learning of the “stay behind” force while serving as a junior Defense Minister in 1966. 

His Foreign Office query strongly suggests British intelligence played a role in Piano Solo, and that the Italian President was well-aware of the plot.

Doomed Italian PM Aldo Moro’s photo while in captivity of the Red Brigades

“one or more of Moro’s kidnappers was secretly in touch with the security apparatus”

On March 16th 1978, a unit of the leftist militant Red Brigades kidnapped Moro. He was on his way to a high-level meeting where he planned to give his blessing there to a new coalition government that relied on communist support, when the kidnappers violently extracted him from his convoy. Five of Moro’s bodyguards were murdered in the process.

After almost two months in captivity, when it became clear the government would neither negotiate with the Red Brigades nor release any of its jailed members in return for Moro, the kidnappers executed the former Italian Prime Minister. His bullet-riddled corpse was left in a car trunk to rot, and for authorities to find.

Moro’s murder has inspired widespread and well-founded suspicions that Gladio operatives infiltrated the Red Brigades to push the group to commit excessively violent acts in order to foment popular demand for a right-wing law-and-order regime. More than perhaps any other incident, his killing fulfilled the objectives of the security state’s strategy of tension. 

Whether or not Moro was a casualty of Gladio, a declassified November 5th 1990 Foreign Office memo authored by Britain’s then-ambassador to Rome, John Ashton, makes it clear that London knew much more about the case than has ever been disclosed publicly by any official source. (Read the full Ashton note here).

“There is circumstantial evidence one or more of Moro’s kidnappers was secretly in touch with the security apparatus at the time; and that the latter deliberately neglected to follow up leads which might have led to the kidnappers and saved Moro’s life,” Ashton declared.

What’s more, according to the British diplomat, the presidential crisis committee responsible for attempting to rescue Moro was part of the notorious P2 – the “subversive Masonic lodge” composed of political elites loyal to Gladio. 

According to Ashton, P2 was just one of many “mysterious right wing forces” striving “by terrorism and street violence to provoke a repressive backlash against Italy’s democratic institutions” under the “strategy of tension.” And President Cossiga was completely unaware it had infiltrated his crisis committee.

In April 1981, magistrates in Milan raided the villa of Licio Gelli, an Italian financier and self-identified fascist who founded P2. There, they uncovered a list of 2,500 members which read like a “Who’s Who” of Italian politicians, bankers, spooks, financiers, industrialists, and senior law enforcement and military officials. Among the cabal’s most  prominent members was Silvio Berlusconi.

Future Italian Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi’s P2 file

Moro’s “historic compromise,” under which the communists “made possible Andreotti’s government”, would be the party’s “final step before their own entry into government.” Ashton stated that this development “was anathema to P2,” which was “then in virtual control of [Italy’s] security apparatus,” and also to many non-P2 establishment politicians, and also to the US,” and sought to “eliminate once and for all any possibility that the Communist Party…might achieve national power.”

Ashton acknowledged “circumstantial evidence” of “US support for P2.” In reality, P2 founder Gelli was so well-connected to Washington’s national security and intelligence apparatus, the CIA’s Rome station had explicitly charged him with establishing an anti-communist parallel government in Rome.

Subsequent investigations showed how Henry Kissinger helped oversee the recruitment of 400 high-ranking Italian and NATO officers as P2 operatives in 1969. The US was so grateful for Gelli’s anti-communist purge that it made him a guest of honor at the inauguration ceremonies of US Presidents Gerald Ford, Jimmy Carter and Ronald Reagan.

Ashton concluded his revealing note by noting the truth about Washington’s involvement in Rome’s bloodspattered “Years of Lead” would “probably never be known.” The full extent of Britain’s involvement in terrorist attacks, government overthrows, destabilization campaigns and other heinous skullduggery under the aegis of Operation Gladio, not merely in Italy but throughout Europe, will almost certainly remain a secret as well, and by design.

It was not until 1993 that the public learned how the US and British gifted munitions to Gladio operatives to foment bloody acts of terror across Italy. As Francesco Fulci told his NATO friends at the “super-restricted” meeting, Washington and London supplied the perpetrators of mass casualty attacks including the 1980 bombing of Bologna Centrale railway station, which killed 85 people and wounded over 200.

Those responsible for these hideous crimes have eluded justice in almost every case. Several of the Bologna massacre’s chief suspects, including committed fascist and confirmed MI6 asset Robert Fiore, escaped to London. Britain refused to extradite him and his co-conspirators despite their convictions in absentia for violent crimes.

The extensive experience British intelligence obtained in Operation Gladio raises questions about the lessons the MI6 has applied to current covert operations in theaters of conflict. As The Grayzone revealed in November 2022, British military and intelligence veterans have trained and sponsored a secret partisan terror army in eastern Ukraine to carry out acts of sabotage in Crimea and other majority-Russian areas. The plan called for the training of cells of ideologically dedicated Ukrainians to “shoot, move, communicate, survive.”


Read the whole story
sarcozona
21 hours ago
reply
Come the fuck on
Epiphyte City
Share this story
Delete

Can a smart home fill in caregiving gaps? | STAT

1 Share

As Peter strode across 20th Street, his mother’s apartment building came into view. Her one-bedroom home in Philadelphia’s historic Rittenhouse Square area was a four-minute walk from the three-story row house where he lived with his wife and two children.

His pace was brisk because he was a man in a hurry, busy with the demanding work of middle-aged life as a father to two grade schoolers, husband to a wife, and leader of a startup medical device company. This visit was part of his fourth job.

Peter is one among the 11 million Americans performing the work of caregiving. His responsibility is his mother, who is one of the 6 million people living with disabling cognitive impairments caused by dementia. Today’s caregiving task — a consequence of escalating challenges in her ability to use devices and appliances — was peculiar.

STAT+

Already have an account? Log in

View All Plans

To read the rest of this story subscribe to STAT+.

Subscribe
Read the whole story
sarcozona
1 day ago
reply
Epiphyte City
Share this story
Delete

Health insurers trying to avoid costly Medicare enrollees draw scrutiny | STAT

1 Share

Major health insurers are taking drastic steps to discourage older adults from signing up for their private Medicare plans as they seek to boost profits, drawing the ire of insurance brokers and state regulators.

Humana, UnitedHealthcare, Anthem, and Centene, and regional insurers like SummaCare, are among the firms that are halting or cutting commissions on Medicare plans. Some are even cutting off access to online enrollment portals, according to company notices obtained by STAT. Many of those decisions occurred after Oct. 15, when Medicare’s annual enrollment period started. It ends Dec. 7.

Companies have overhauled their 2026 Medicare Advantage and Medicare prescription drug plans in an attempt to boost profits and adapt to the Inflation Reduction Act. An estimated 3 million people are in soon-to-be-terminated Medicare Advantage plans and have to choose new coverage. Over the past few years, the Medicare markets have become an increasingly feverish game of hot potato — with Humana, CVS Health’s Aetna, and now UnitedHealthcare altering benefits and drug formularies with the intention of pushing their sicker, costlier customers to choose a competitor’s plan.

STAT+

Already have an account? Log in

View All Plans

To read the rest of this story subscribe to STAT+.

Subscribe
Read the whole story
sarcozona
1 day ago
reply
Epiphyte City
Share this story
Delete
Next Page of Stories